Eagle AI Agency

Notes

Why is nobody booking from your website?

By Matthew Eagle

Founder, Eagle AI Agency. Eight years as a staffing account executive.

Published . Updated .

This week a booking calendar on a site we look after went blank, and a job link we sent opened a page saying the job did not exist. Both pages loaded fine. Here is what we found and the check we run every week now.

If people visit your website and nobody books, check the booking step itself before you change the ads or rewrite the copy. Open the site on a phone and a computer, click all the way through to a confirmed booking or a delivered form, and repeat that every week. A page can load perfectly while the calendar on it is empty or the link on it leads nowhere, and nothing will alert you when that happens.

What did we find broken this week?

Two things, both on the step where a visitor is supposed to act.

A booking calendar that showed an empty box

On a site we look after, the booking calendar on the contact page and inside the pop-up had stopped showing. The page loaded. The space where the calendar belonged was blank.

We found out on a call reviewing paid ad results. The clicks were coming in and the bookings were not, because the clicks were landing on a page where nobody could book.

The cause was ours. When we built the page, we gave the box that holds the calendar the same label the booking tool uses for its own box. The two got in each other's way, the calendar never started, and the box stayed empty.

A job link that opened a page saying the job was gone

The same week, a link we sent to candidates opened a page that said the job could not be found. The address was real and the page opened. It pointed at the internal record for the job instead of the public posting, and the public site had nothing at that address.

A candidate replied to tell us the link didn't work. That reply is how we found out, and the link had been wrong since the day it first went out.

Why doesn't a broken booking page tell you it's broken?

From the website's side, nothing failed. The page was served, the link opened, no error was thrown, so nothing had a reason to raise a flag.

The failure only exists in what a person sees, and a basic check never looks at what a person sees. A check that asks whether an address answers will not read the page and notice that it says the job could not be found.

Visitors don't report it either. Someone who can't book rarely writes in to say so. They close the tab. The candidate who took the time to tell us was the exception.

It's the same trap we wrote about in what breaks when you automate a process nobody is watching: a system can look healthy while doing nothing.

What does a visitor see that a quick check misses?

What a visitor can still see when a quick check passes

What you checkWhat a quick check tells youWhat a visitor can still see
The booking pageThe page loadsAn empty box where the calendar should be
A link in an email or messageThe link opensA page saying what they came for isn't there
The contact formIt shows a thank-you messageNothing, because the message never reached anyone
The pop-upIt works on the screen you built it onSomething different on a phone or another browser

How do you test your booking page the way a visitor would?

  1. 1Use a real browser. Open the page and look at it. Both of our failures were on pages that loaded fine.
  2. 2Check on a phone and a computer, in more than one browser. Your visitors use all of them.
  3. 3Go all the way through. Pick a time, fill in the form, press submit.
  4. 4Confirm the other end. The booking shows up on your calendar. The form lands in the inbox someone actually reads. A thank-you screen only proves the site accepted it.
  5. 5Check every place the booking appears. The contact page, the pop-up, and any page an ad sends people to.
  6. 6Open every link before you send it. Especially links into a system that keeps separate internal and public addresses for the same thing.
  7. 7Put it on a schedule. Once a week, same day, whether or not anything changed.

What did we change after this week?

We fixed the calendar on the contact page and in the pop-up, and set the pop-up to open as soon as the page loads on every device. We corrected the job link.

My instruction afterward was short: make sure this never happens again, and check it weekly. So now, every Monday morning, an automated check opens the site in more than one browser at phone, laptop and desktop sizes. It loads the calendar on the contact page and in the pop-up, submits the form, and confirms the careers link. Results post to the channel the team works in.

The first full run passed every check, and a test form submission came through to the inbox and the team alert. One limit, stated plainly: the check only covers the pages it was built to open. A new landing page has to be added to it, or it goes unchecked.

For links, the rule is now that every apply or booking link gets opened in a real browser before it goes out.

If your site is where new customers book you, it deserves the same weekly look as anything else that brings in money. How we build sites around getting that booking is on our website design page.

Questions people ask

How often should I test my website's booking form?

Once a week, plus any time you or anyone else changes the site, the booking settings or the form. Ours broke when the page was built, so a change is exactly when to look.

Can a link work and still be broken?

Yes. The link can open a real page that says the thing you were looking for is missing. The only way to catch it is to read the page the link opens, the way a visitor would.

Does a thank-you message mean my contact form works?

No. It means your site accepted the form. Check that the message actually landed in an inbox someone reads, because that is the half visitors can't see.

What should I check first if bookings suddenly drop?

The booking step itself, on a phone, all the way to a confirmed booking. It takes a few minutes, and it rules out the cheapest problem to fix before you spend time or money on ads and copy.

Want to talk through your own booking path? Book a call.

More notes

Want the version of this for your business?

Twenty minutes, your actual situation, a straight answer about what we would do first.

Book a 20 minute call

20 minutes. You leave with a straight answer.